If I had tons of money…

I’d hire a crack team to develop software for videogame character modeling that is similar to the modeling system used in the upcoming game Spore.

The premise is simple: You open a program on your computer that is only based around modeling characters or animals. You create things like legs, arms, heads, torsos, and any other body accessories you wish using a simple, to-the-point editor. Really newb friendly. After painting your texture like spraypaint (or by importing from an image), the modeling program procedurally generates the animations and exports to an industry-standard, open-source model + animation format that every major 3D engine supports.

Of course, we’re miles and miles away from something this useful.

The current system for developing models using computers is absolutely horrendous. It’s not that I’m criticizing the functionality of any of the major modeling programs or teams. Far from it. Obviously those artists who spend the time, get an education in the field, and are uniquely talented can and do create some fantastic scenes for us all to view whether it be still shots, games, or video.

The problem is that the tools are too extensive for the needs of an indie videogame designer. If you don’t know how to model, texture wrap, rig, animate, export, and then import your models, or you don’t know anyone who does, or if you have no funds to pay for someone to model for you, then you’re simply not going to be able to make a 3D game and tell your story. In this case, your only solution is to go 2D with tools like  RPG Maker VX or Torque Game Builder, which are at the top of their class for 2D.

It’s disappointing because there are so many neat 3D games started by so many small teams these days and we’ve all got a large amount of free (or very low cost) 3D technology, but unless you’ve got a lot of time, a lot of money, or somehow a lifetime of game development knowledge, it’s very hard to produce an indie 3D game.

There are companies who are striving (and doing great work I might add) to give indies a chance by building just the tools I am blogging about (case in point: GarageGames), but there is still one area where complexity reigns supreme: modeling and animation.

Let’s look at the current setup.

First, as an aspiring modeler you’ve basically got two choices: a powerful yet completely unintuitive open-source solution (Blender), or software piracy to download and use an industry-standard but insanely expensive and closed solution (Lightwave, Maya, 3DS Max, et. al).

Then, after installing the software, the file formats that each program use are not entirely and completely interchangeable. It’s a bit like the different floppy disk formats of the 1980s. The files on each of the disks were the same but each had a special format, key, physical size difference, or other attribute that kept them almost entirely proprietary.

In between each of these programs is a completely unique interface. It’s not like the difference between Google Docs, Open Office, and Microsoft Word, of which you might spend a total of 30 seconds figuring out where everything is. No, these all feature user interfaces that contain so many powerful tools that they have their own scrollbar. We’re literally talking feature overload, here.

A few examples:

After you finally make your model and texture it, you have to rig it by placing bones and joints inside manually that will give your player the skeleton it needs in order to move. That sentence might take you weeks to finish if you’ve never done it before. With your skeleton in place you need to animate it by using a keyframer. As your skeleton moves, your model’s body will follow suit.

Hopefully and with any luck, the program you’re using will have an exporter that will export your model in the format your game engine can support. For Quake and Half Life that was Md2. For Torque, it’s DTS.

If by this point you’ve like me and you’re wondering why modeling a character for your 3D videogame can’t be simpler then at least I’m not alone! So, what’s the solution at this stage of the game? You tell me.